Amazon vs. Babylist vs. Target: Which Baby Registry?
The registry you pick matters less than what you put on it, but it does matter, and mostly in ways you'll only notice afterwards: when you return the duplicate bouncer, when you buy the leftovers at a discount, when your aunt can't work out how to check out.
Program terms change and vary by region, so we describe what each one does rather than quote percentages. Confirm the current details on the registry's own page before you rely on them.
Side by side
| Amazon | Babylist | Target | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What you can add | Amazon's catalog | Anything from any store, plus cash funds and help like meals | Target's catalog |
| Group gifting | On eligible items | Cash funds toward anything | Limited |
| Completion discount | Yes, on remaining items for a window after the due date; better with Prime | Yes, at partner stores for a window | Yes, a one-time coupon for a window |
| Returns | Extended window for registry items; by mail | Depends on the store the item came from | In-store, with an extended window for registry items |
| Welcome gift | A box, with conditions | A box, with conditions | A kit, picked up in store |
| Easiest for | Relatives who already shop on Amazon; fast shipping | Parents who want one link for everything | Anyone who wants to walk in and return something |
Amazon
The widest catalog and the fastest shipping, which matters more than it sounds when the baby comes early. The completion discount on what's left after your due date is genuinely useful for the boring things — diapers, wipes, the second set of sheets — and registry returns get a longer window than ordinary orders.
The weakness is curation: it's easy to add the wrong thing, and the reviews are a mix of the useful and the fake. Use a checklist you trust, add exactly the pick you want, and don't browse.
Babylist
A universal registry: add the crib from one store, the carrier from another, a cash fund for the stroller, and a request for a week of dinners, all on one link. For a registry with an opinion — one pick per thing, some of them from small brands — it's the natural home.
Returns follow whichever store the item actually came from, so keep track. And cash funds are wonderful for the big three but some relatives will always rather buy a thing than give money; leave them a few things to buy.
Target
The registry for people who want to return things in person. Walk in, hand it over, done. The completion coupon and the welcome kit are pleasant, and the catalog covers the essentials from brands most people recognize.
The catalog is narrower and the premium picks — the stroller, the glider — may not be there. Many families pair Target with a universal registry for exactly that reason.
Our recommendation
- One registry, keep it simple: Babylist, and add the Amazon and Target items to it as links.
- Relatives who won't cope with anything new: Amazon, and be strict about what you add.
- You return things and want it painless: Target for the essentials, a universal registry for the rest.
- Whatever you choose, turn on group gifting for the car seat, stroller and glider, and finish the registry in one sitting with a checklist.
Read next
Get the checklist for your stage
One email per stage. No newsletter, no noise.